Recently the SACN (Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition) has clarified how the UK definition of free sugars applies to processed fruit and vegetables. This is because although there’s “no evidence of harm from sugars that stay locked inside the cell structure of whole foods, processing that breaks down that structure releases them as free sugars”.
In the new guidance, processes are grouped by whether the fruit or vegetable stays largely intact:
Group 1 (free sugars): liquidising, blending, pulping, sieving, mashing, pressing and crushing; stewing that leaves the food no longer intact (e.g. apples, tomatoes); making concentrates, extruded snacks, powders, and freeze-dried or fully dehydrated products.
Group 2 (no free sugars): chopping, slicing, dicing and grating; drying that leaves the structure largely intact (e.g. raisins, dried apricots).
The definition applies equally to:
Home cooked and manufactured products, although they acknowledge that industrial processing is more likely to release sugars than home cooking
Vegetables and fruit, although vegetables contain less sugar to begin with
Despite this clarification, the SACN emphasises that processed fruit and vegetables are a relatively small source of free sugars in the UK. It states that “added sugars still make up about three-quarters of free sugars intake in children aged 10 and under, and around 80% in older children and adults” and that “purées and vegetable juices contribute only a few percent, though the share is higher in toddlers”.
They also acknowledge that, applying these new definitions are still difficult because:
Most labels show total or added sugars, not free sugars
There’s little evidence on how much sugar different processes release
Products that mix whole, juiced and puréed ingredients are hard to assess
SACN repeats its advice to:
Get no more than 5% of daily energy from free sugars
Eat at least five portions of a variety of fruit and vegetables a day
What is the KFDC’s position on free sugars from processed fruit and veg?
This is an especially tricky area, particularly when it comes to children’s food because so many products in this sector contain processed fruit and/or veg. However, that doesn’t mean we don’t take it into account when assessing the relative healthiness of products.
We feel that a much more significant issue is that many children’s products are high in refined and added sugars, and as the SACN guidance states, this is where the majority of free sugars in children’s diets come from. We support products that a) encourage all children, but particularly older kids, to eat less refined sugar b) are a source of fibre c) get children eating fruit that may normally eat little to none.
As the SACN suggests, application of their guidance is not easy because on-pack nutritional information doesn’t differentiate between free sugars and other types of intrinsic sugars (such as those that come from milk). This is why the KFDC does make a distinction in its criteria, as well as having strict rules around the levels/type of processing and target age range of these products.
Even so, we recognise that some products within the KFDC may be higher in free sugars that come from processed fruit (as defined by the SACN) and we would never claim them to be as healthy as fresh fruits and vegetables. But fresh, whole fruit is not always practical and for some children’s products the level of free sugar is partially offset by a higher than average fibre content, meaning they can have a place in children’s diets as a healthier alternative to confectionery or snacks with added refined sugar.
Similarly with fruit juice drinks, we acknowledge that although fruit juice is relatively high in free sugars, when reviewed in the context of the other children’s drinks currently available, and when consumed in moderation, for older children it can represent a preferable alternative to drinks that contain added refined sugars or artificial sweeteners, particularly when mixed with water.
For us, the key word is healthier, not healthiest. We believe that change will only happen by meeting parents where they are, not lecturing them about where they should be, and by helping them make informed and confident decisions that work for them and their children.
Read the full SACN guidance here.

